Rebel Moon: Part 1 | The Director's Cut is the Only Version That Matters

3.5/5

Is Rebel Moon: Part 1 a good movie? Absolutely. I'm referring to the R-rated director's cut, not the lackluster PG-13 version initially released by Netflix. This film exemplifies the power of a director's unrestrained vision, free from studio interference.

A Familiar Yet Compelling Quest

Zack Snyder embarked on crafting a story that, while not entirely original, is compelling in its own right. Critics may draw parallels to the Star Wars universe and its narratives, but such themes have been explored in The Lord of the Rings and countless other tales before. This film is Snyder's unique take on a quest-driven heroic epic, and it is indeed well-executed.

A Visual Feast Enhanced by Its Rating

This is the first Snyder film in a long time that truly captivated me, evoking the same awe I felt after watching 300. The cinematography bears his unmistakable signature style, featuring crushed blacks and a comic book aesthetic, punctuated by slow-motion blood explosions. Such elements thrive in an R-rated environment, as evidenced by the initial negative reviews of the PG-13 version. Unfortunately, many early viewers might not revisit this three-hour epic because of their first impressions. Personally, I'm glad I gave it another chance after struggling to get through the initial release, of which I couldn't get past the 20-min mark.

Stronger Characters and Stellar Editing

The acting is strong, with characters that now feel fleshed out and engaging. The cast choices make sense in this context, which wasn't apparent in the earlier version. The film's pacing benefits from skillful editing that adeptly manages tension and release.

A Thunderous Score

Tom Holkenborg's score complements the narrative effectively. While it may lack memorable themes or melodies that linger after viewing, it serves its purpose well—enhancing on-screen action and stepping back when necessary. Industry insiders might speculate about ghostwriting contributions to Holkenborg's work, but ultimately, the music supports the film's dynamic scenes with thunderous intensity.

The Director's Cut Is the Definitive Version

Overall, I enjoyed Rebel Moon: Part 1. The low ratings likely stem from reactions to the initial cut rather than this superior director's version. Some criticisms may also come from armchair elitist critics who expect every film to be life-altering. However, for those seeking an engaging cinematic experience with Snyder's distinct flair, this director's cut is the definitive version to watch.